| Pos. | Season | Timegap | Winner | 2nd |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | '07-'08 | 00:00:00 | MANDERFIELD Kacey | JONES Kelly |
| 2 | '10-'11 | 00:00:01 | JAMES Ashley | WINFIELD Deidre |
| 3 | '08-'09 | 00:00:01 | SWARTZ Melanie | DALLAIRE Annajean |
| 4 | '15-'16 | 00:00:04 | ANTHONY Crystal | MILLER Amanda |
| 5 | '17-'18 | 00:00:05 | WEST Ruby | WILLIAMS Lily |
| 6 | '09-'10 | 00:00:08 | WINFIELD Deidre | KEOUGH Kaitie |
| 7 | '14-'15 | 00:00:12 | ORTON Beth Ann | NOBLE Ellen |
| 8 | '23-'24 | 00:00:19 | MANI Caroline | CLOUSE Katie |
| 9 | '11-'12 | 00:00:19 | WOODRUFF Chloe | THIEMANN Nicole |
| 10 | '16-'17 | 00:00:21 | KEMMERER Arley | MAXIMENKO Cassandra |
| 11 | '21-'22 | 00:00:26 | ARENSMAN Hannah | GUNSALUS Lizzy |
| 12 | '13-'14 | 00:00:30 | GILBERT Sunny | ORTON Beth Ann |
| 13 | '22-'23 | 00:00:46 | MANI Caroline | ZOERNER Lauren |
| 14 | '06-'07 | 00:00:47 | WINFIELD Deidre | WALLACE Amy |
| 15 | '12-'13 | 00:00:56 | CAREY Amanda | ARNOLD Katie |
| 16 | '19-'20 | 00:01:00 | ARENSMAN Hannah | NUSS Raylyn |